Did You try push an "Enter" after the selection criteria?
Yes. Tried that multiple times.
Also tried filtering on different fields, limiting the number of filter prompts, iis reset, clearing cache / temp files, etc.
I'm not sure if this is an issue is that the action was created off of a collection based on the Configuration Item object which is where this default query is defined. I saw a couple of older articles regarding an issue with that back in 7.4 or earlier where this wouldn't work unless the window it was using was the default. So we also tried setting the window as the default and that unfortunately did not work either.